Episode 196 Recap

Episode 196 Recap

Shut Up and Sing Isn’t a Plan

Musicians and politics have never had a clean relationship, and the “just shut up and sing” crowd keeps ignoring one basic problem: staying quiet gets you criticized too. This week’s episode digs into why artists get dragged into political fights whether they signed up or not.

The Great American State Fair is a tidy example. Nine artists were announced for the two-week National Mall celebration of America’s 250th birthday, and within two days six of them said they had never agreed to play. Some claimed they were pitched a non-partisan event and found out otherwise. By the weekend, Vanilla Ice was the last act standing. Meanwhile, Bruce Springsteen and Tom Morello announced a festival of their own, all while Springsteen was drawing a boycott call from the president. Two stages, one country, and a lot of musicians doing the math on which one they could afford to be seen at.

Politicians have been borrowing songs for decades without listening to them. Reagan name-checked Springsteen in 1984, apparently on the strength of a Born in the USA chorus that hides a verse about a Vietnam veteran who can’t catch a break. Springsteen answered by playing a song off Nebraska. Tom Petty sent a cease and desist to George W. Bush’s campaign, and Fortunate Son keeps getting played by people who stop reading at the title. Clinton asked Fleetwood Mac first, and they ended up playing his inaugural ball. The Dixie Chicks learned the other side of it in 2003, when one comment in London cost them country radio.

Then there’s the reverse, when events force the music. Kent State, May 4, 1970: four students killed, nine wounded, and Neil Young writing Ohio within days. Mark went to college at Akron, Kent’s rival, and says that was one subject nobody joked about. No one knows whether a song has ever changed a vote. But the candidates leave office and the songs stay put, still being misheard.

The Songs

Ron Gallo’s “Yellow No. 5” takes the bones of Mambo No. 5 and turns it into a list of everything wrong with the modern world, from fries to politics. It sits somewhere between folk rock and punk, with a loose, live-in-the-room feel and sharp lyrics. Unserious source material, serious social commentary, and it works.

Radio Free Alice delivers “The Intersection,” a track with echoes of The Cure and The Smiths that would have fit right in on a college radio station in the 80s or 90s. The vocals are in a category of their own, and the whole thing carries that jangly, moody vibe in a good way.

Cleveland’s Jack and the Optimists made an impression opening for Banda AL9 at the Beachland Tavern, and “The Acquaintance” shows why. Call it alternative pop with 60s and 70s songwriting craft and an edge, with traces of The Beatles and Cream. If you like the Jelly Bricks, start here. He’s having shoulder surgery soon, so send good thoughts.

“A Minute on the Lips” from Little Grandad closes things out, and its best trick is silence. The rests give each section room to breathe, which most new music refuses to do. Jangly pop rock with a tight rhythm section, strong guitars, and good vocals. A new album arrives in 2027, so follow them now.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *